Blender UI paper cuts

lol guys :smile:


Following the file browser party, why the header is at the bottom and hidden by default? :upside_down_face:

2020-02-24_23-01-17

Why not move it to the top and make it visible by default? :upside_down_face:

8 Likes

Well I suspect because itā€™s almost empty, takes up space and is superfluous since all the entries from the menus are available in the popovers to the right. I could be wrong, though.

2 Likes

then letā€™s turn filebrowser into a headerless type of window (with dancing icons)

One thing that annoys me is that Iā€™m so used to press the first letter of the file/folder that I want to open to not scroll or search for it, but sadly this doesnā€™t work in the file browser.

8 Likes

Agreed, I tried to do just that the other day (out of habit) and obviously it didnā€™t work. It would be quite nice to have !

and some particle effects when you click something (anything!)

Not sure which OS you are referring to, but as under windows you can type in longer searchphrases in the filelist, Iā€™d be happy there would be an option in the preferences for the openFileDialog/openFileBrowser in blender to start with focus on the search function. Thatā€™s not exactly the same behaviour as autoscrolling in the filelist but would be similar enough for me. But for sure making the filelist scroll to the first entry would be as welcome.

Yes, or remove it completely. Currently itā€™s really just about Select All, None and Invert. Shortcuts for these could be added and the whole menu could be removed

I have 3 wishes (for the filebrowser)

  1. Allow file operations on files and folders via drag and drop in the filebrowser, especially dropping files and folders into other folders.

  2. Remove the current folder drop feature to open them. At least forbid dragging folders from within the filebrowser itself to change the directory. That operation canā€™t even be cancelled once it has been accidently triggered as ESC does close the dialog instead. In thumbnailview this happens much quicker than in the listview though.

ctrlclicks

This is especially confusing since Iā€™d rather expect to see the droptargets content if a change happens but not the dragsource content. I see why this is happening but itā€™s strange anyhow.

  1. Unify ctrl clicks in the filebrowser.
  • Ctrl+LMB clicks on selected file deselects it
  • Ctrl+LMB clicks on selected folder deselects it
  • Ctrl+LMB clicks on deselected file selects it
  • Ctrl+LMB clicks on deselected folder changes the directory.

ctrlClicks

These are all ctrl clicks btw.

9 Likes

I am blindly voting for this!

1 Like

The knife tool does not display options when being invoked by a hotkey.
The only way to change ā€œocclude geometryā€ and ā€œonly selectedā€ is by going through the menu or the icon in the t-menu.

Ideally the options should be setable before the first cut is being made.
Even better if a cut thatā€™s being edited

1 Like

In the Preferences Iā€™m always searching for the option to switch off the viewport navigation controls in theā€¦ Navigation section. :slightly_smiling_face:

For the sake of logic Iā€™d love to see the option being moved to the Navigation section. Thanks!

3 Likes

I think no because it makes more sense as it is now, despite the matching word ā€œNavigationā€ that can play you tricks :wink:
Look at that, in Navigation panel you have mostly options that control how you navigate in 3d view, while in the interface you find what is shown on screen in various editors, including the navigation widget. Sounds good to me.

2 Likes

I think you mean the knife modal operator ? the options are accessible from the hotkeys, which are shown in the info bar at the bottom of the window. Theyā€™re the same used in the tool, as far as I know (z, c, shift and ctrl).

Iā€™m thinking dangerously but : why not show them in two different places ? could be misleading, but easier to find, kind of a ā€œtagā€ system (one item can correspond to several ā€œcategoriesā€ or ā€œplacesā€).

that was my first thought butā€¦ naaah too dangerous! :stuck_out_tongue:

Yes, somewhat - I did find out (or better - was reminded) about them later. The nodal operators donā€™t save the last setting, do they? Also at least ā€œOnly selectedā€ does not seem to be reachable by nodal shortcuts and to me it feels weird that there are operators which are simply only reachably by keyboard only. But if thatā€™s by design then thatā€™s the way it is. I also found out that [Alt] followed by [K] invokes the tool instead of the nodal which I found out by total accident. If the tool would display it somehow like C4D does (ā€œAlt ~ Kā€) then at least this would have been clearer. Maxon use ā€œ~ā€ as a way to communicate a key succession as opposed to a Key combination.
Itā€™s okay now that I know but it certainly wasnā€™t too intuitive to find out.

ON a totally different note (maybe I will be corrected here as well): Adaptive grid size seems to be not working in 3D view.
In orthographic view the grid adjusts when zooming in and out and also displays the current measurement of the grid. Cool!
In 3D view it doesnā€™t. If you want to work in perspective with a smaller grid (in centimeters for example) you have to adjust the size in the viewport overlay. Which in turn screws with the display in orthographic again (because it shows an adjusted value).

The grid should scale to

1 Like

Ok, so this one tripped me up for a bit:

GIF 27.02.2020 14-41-12

Can you guess whatā€™s wrong here?

Spoiler

Edit mode as activated.

6 Likes

Whatā€™s the beef here?
Tried to uncheck ā€œlock object modesā€ in the edit menu? (terrible place for this setting btw)

image

The beef is that I shouldnā€™t even be able to have that semi-selection-highlight move around when I click in the outliner when Iā€™m in edit mode.

If, instead, say that highlight would have just flashed a little bit and disappeared, it could have highlighted to me that something else was up.

(I didnā€™t know about that option you showed, btw, so thanks for that.)

4 Likes

Same goes for moving objects, it seems. If you select a hierarchy, and then drag it over to another collection in the outliner, only a single object will be moved.

If you, however, use ā€œmove to collectionā€ in the viewport, they all move over.

1 Like

About those selection highlights, I hate them. :slight_smile:

My man Red wax once requested an alpha option in the themes for that selection highlight so we could be able to turn that off if we wished so, but still no love.
The text in the outliner already changes color when selected, why on earth do I need those giant bar highlights. Thatā€™s just too much clutter to me.

2 Likes

Thereā€™s no right-click option to ā€œchange shortcutā€ for menus with submenus:

image

3 Likes