Thanks for chiming in, and putting things in perspective. I didn’t want to sound cheeky, I guess it’s just so easy to tune out the fact that everyone has a real life out there 
2 Likes
Have you thought about starting crowdfunding to explore whether such a project could be profitable? With the option of offering a Metal Cycles fork in the App Store?
1 Like
I haven’t considered that seriously. I’d rather something like this were done more officially as part of the Blender roadmap. Though I suppose crowdfunding might be an interesting way to pass funds thru to the Blender foundation earmarked for this work. Not sure if it ever works that way.
3 Likes
Again: Brecht is afaik the only developer on BF payroll working on Cycles (though just today they started looking for a second dev). Pretty much all of the new cycles stuff in the last 2 years or so was done by external contributors such as devs working in studios, gsoc students or developers employed by nvidia / amd / Intel
I’m not even sure if Brecht did any development on Cycles but reviewing patches in the last couple of months
4 Likes
Well, Apple could you know, contribute a developer that does the Metal, like NVIDIA and AMD did for their parts. 
12 Likes
Seriously, why give a completely closed hardware platform any sort of support, this is after all Free Software whose ethos is literally opposite of what Apple stands for. They deliberately bend over backwards to be incompatible.
I don’t care what’s free software or not. From user perspective I want to use what I feel the best for me. Paid or free I don’t care. I love to work on a mac, that fits for my needs mostly.
We’re just getting ideas here, not begging. It would be great to use a metal powered Blender. Why is that a problem for you? With a bigger perspective of support this software wont be less or anything. You’re just taking this personal here.
9 Likes
Everyone, if you have something substantive to contribute regarding Metal and Cycles, or want to voice your support, please do. If not, please have the discussion elsewhere.
14 Likes
hi all, as someone with physical disabilities, chiming in to voice my support for doing anything that will improve the ability to use blender on macs .
I love both blender and macs-- in some ways I’m locked into the mac platform because the only mouse that really works for me is the original Magic Mouse. I have muscular dystrophy, and what tends to happen for people like me is that as our muscles deteriorate, our bodies conform to the technology that we are using (mice, keyboards, wheelchairs), and it’s difficult or impossible to switch to something else later because over time we no longer have those muscles.
tl;dr, ensuring mac/blender compatibility is wonderful for accessibility!
if you’re curious to see more on the topic:
- article by my awesome friend Arc (though he doesn’t use macs) https://medium.com/@ARC4G/how-i-use-blender-with-a-disability-7c8e6bc5e02f
- thread he started Blender and accessibility for people with disabilities
17 Likes
1 Like
Finally! I hope it supports older versions of macOS because I run Catalina. I would hate to be so close to GPU rendering only to fall short at the last second.
I hate to disappoint, but William did not look at any patches for Metal support, we don’t currently have those. He looked at a patch for animation denoising, and discussions/ideas regarding Metal and Path Guiding.
If we have concrete news to share regarding Metal we’ll do it, you won’t find it hidden in a weekly report.
5 Likes
Thank you for clarifying that. So we don’t have to hold our breath for gpu rendering for the next year or so, do we?
We can’t give any time estimate regarding this.
1 Like
Just the fact that someone says the timeline isn’t concrete and not just “we are not considering Metal” is good enough right now.
3 Likes
I have a stupid question (probably).
I’m working on a Mac. When I use the viewport render preview (Cycles) my activity monitor indicates that both, the CPU a n d GPU are working at 100% usage.
Also when I render an image the GPU is working (maybe 20-80% - depending on the scene).
In other CPU render engines the GPU isn’t working at all when rendering.
Why is that? Does Cycles on MacOS still use the GPU for some calculations?
Tells us about the content discussed about supporting metal? Because there is no good gpu as of now?
Out of curiosity I played with the latest cycles-x branch and tried to port it to metal - more or less as a personal exercise.
The first annoying thing was, that the metal compiler needs an explicit address space qualifier for each and every pointer or reference, which floods the code with it, but at least it is probably solvable with brute force and much typing. It would be nice, if Apple would add at least add a compiler flag to treat every pointer as “thread”, except it has an other qualifier.
The bigger problem is, that metal until now (2.4) does not support lambdas, which are used in the cycles code quite a lot. The next metal version will usually be presented at the next WWDC 2022 and it is not guaranteed, that this will be included. It would technically for sure be possible to rewrite it or maintain two versions of these parts, but that would uglify everything and is not very tempting.
Fore sure there are more obstacles, but I did only scratch the surface so far.
So my questions to the developer team are:
Do you know more? If my observations are correct, would you wait for Apple do catch up the other platforms with the metal framework in order to not fragment the cycles code even more? (would mean no cycles metal port before summer 2022)
12 Likes
So, the news is that Apple is contributing a Metal backend to Cycles. The relevant task is here:
https://developer.blender.org/T92212
We’ve been talking to Apple about this for a while, but have not been able to share it until now.
49 Likes
Big news probably related timing wise to the m1x arm macs being announced Monday
15 Likes